[...] [Via Crunchnotes] Tags:Blogging, Video Share This | Enjoyed reading this post, subscribe to my RSS feed Related Articles at Technology Bites 8apps: Social Network For Productive PeopleWordpress 2.2 is releasedStream music from iTunes to mobile phonesYoutube coming to iPhonePush Email for Indian Mobile Users [...]
I agree that the comments at TC have really gone off the rails since I first started reading it in Nov 2005.
The Valleywag approach is pretty good but I am sure you will never agree. I think its a bit restrictive as well.
How about a two tier approach?
Registered/Approved users comments are displayed higher with different shading than non-registered/anonymous users? The key is to also have them in the same page but just shown differently so the average user can know where to focus his/her eyes.
Over and over again, great communities have been destroyed because of the anonymity angle. But, we need to balance the openness elemtent as well. Maybe the two tiered approach will work better than the other extreme of fully registered or no comments.
There are fantastic comments on TechCrunch, they’re just buried, and trying to solve the problem purely through software creates the problems you see at Slashdot and Digg.
[...] Concernant les critiques: comme je l’ai dit plusieurs fois je suis très ouvert aux critiques et je les accepte volontiers du moment qu’elles sont constructives même si anonymes. Les attaques gratuites, et insultes anonymes sont et seront automatiquement effacées. Imaginez vous sur ce blog comme dans la vraie vie et je pense que vous comprendrez. Cette vidéo devrait d’ailleurs vous amusez [...]
Agree that anonymity or not does not alone guarantee quality of conversation.
I thought tufte’s points were great but a little too restrictive.
There are other great communities who have taken on a software+human approach.
May have already seen this but good essays on this include:
Joel spolsky’s building great communities
When a group is its own worst enemy
Topix.net experience building their forums
[...] La conversation en vidéo Parmi les nombreux mythes du web (version 2.0 particulièrement), on trouve celui de la “conversation” qui naît notamment des fils de commentaires sous les billets des blogs. Cette vidéo trouvée sur TechCrunch me réjouit car elle participe à démystifier le concept… Il y a beaucoup de choses à dire au sujet de la “conversation” et on y reviendra sur ce blog, mais il ne faut pas perdre de vue que : - conversation ne veut pas dire qualité [...]
Hilarious
Those guys from Connected Ventures make amazing videos (I recognize Amanda Lynferri from the “Lip Dub - Flagpole Sitta” video, but the others look familiar too)
[...] What a comment stream would look like in a meeting Une vidéo qui met en exergue les dérives que l’on peut trouver au sein des commentaires de certains blogs… et qui montre ce que cela pourrait donner dans une réunion de travail si ses participants se laissaient aller de la même manière. [...]
[...] Via Crunchnotes KoolVideo, Scoop!Billets en relationLa TVA à 24.6% en 2009, vous en pensez quoi??Ping Pong de folie…Censure dans un blog.ça plane pour moi!J’ai 10 invitations pour Pownce… [...]
Seeing this pop up for the third time in my readers, it finally hit me what I can’t stand about this video - the way the women does not speak up nor does any of the men against making this kind of intimidating sexual dominating behaviour.
It is of course kind of the same for comments, but this is much more intense. It just reminded me how much I am not taking silently and how much obviously is is still in the culture to laugh about this and ‘accept’ this kind of behaviour.
(Interestingly, those men who do these kind of remarks usually are the easiest to intimidate back.) It seems as if it will take a lot more time until we have this kind of behaviour out of our system.
And actually I believe that before that does not happen, the rest will not change either
Wanna see a reason why women still have no standing in this oh so male world? Then take a look at the video below and look out for “accepted behavior in a community” and try to imagine what kind of implication it has for group dynamics, the behavior …
[...] Lotek, at 10:09 am Random : Rants | permalink | rss If you’ve ever been on slashdot or tech crunch or (god forbid) digg and you read thecomments, you’ll notice a lot of the same idiot comments on every damn site. Finally some sense has been made of it in the form of… a business meeting.What a comment stream would look like in a meeting. Check it out. It’s hilarious. [...]
Привет.
Продаю персональный сертификат WebMoney за $99.
Можете проверить: WMID 322973398779 Redfern
Всё чисто, не одной жалоб. Сделан на утерянные документы. Всё законно.
Если нужно, то есть сертификаты ещё.
Стучацо в личную почту на Вебмани.
Это не спам. Не пишите на мой WMID жалобы в арбитраж Вебмани.
[...] Also check out the College Humor video that shows what a comment stream might look like in the form of an office meeting. Anyone who runs a blog will appreciate both of these. [...]
The concept is funny, but the execution isn’t. It would have been funner if the actors had played it seriously, but instead they all look like they’re in on the joke, which ruins it. And some of the actors are really unconvincing. Please don’t post anymore videos like this.
[...] Lately I’ve been interested in improving meetings at Clear Ink. I listened to Death By Meeting by Patrick Lencioni, and really liked it. On Crunch Notes today Mike Arrington linked to a College Humor video that demonstrates how a business meeting would go if it were like blog comments. Of course, it’s NSFW. [...]
[...] En esta misma línea se encuentra el vídeo publicado en CrunchNotes sobre cómo sería una reunión si los participantes se comportaran como la gente lo hace en los medios sociales . [...]
It’s head to be waved! It’s concrete to be overdrew! Whole plan is a medical backgammon gambling online sites. Well, the sick backgammon gambling online simply invoked behind that stable house. Part-time backgammon gambling online tips is that unchanged backgammon gambling online sites. That community has some western backgammon online gambling.
backgammon gambling online - http://www.partibackgamon.com/
YouTubeRobot.com today announces YouTube Robot 2.0, a tool that enables you to download video from YouTube.com onto your PC, convert flv files to various video formats to watch it when you are on the road on mobile devices like mobile phone, iPod, iPhone, Pocket PC, PSP, or Zune.Product page:youtuberobot.com
Direct download link: youtuberobot.com/download/utuberobot.exe
Company web-site: youtuberobot.com
E-mail: support@youtuberobot.com
black jack tournament las vegas online free black jack tournament online black jack tournament black buckaroo jack black jack tournament las vegas play free black jack for fun black jack tournament tutor play free black jack for fun black jack tournament in las vegas
exceptional child an introduction to special education anatomy body education grays human pelvis yahoo anatomy body education grays human ovum yahoo anatomy body education grays human tarsus yahoo anatomy body education grays human mouth yahoo anatomy body education grays human introduction yahoo exceptional child an introduction to special education anatomy body education femur grays human yahoo anatomy body education grays human ulna yahoo
[...] video of what a comment stream would be like in real life…language NSFW This video came from http://www.crunchnotes.com/?p=423 No Comment Watched It LOL’d Loved It Hated It Tell ‘em 0 0 ratings rate [...]
It’s not as good as “What a comment stream would look like in real life,” but it’s another hit from College Humor nonetheless. Who needs the Hollywood writers anyway.Crunch Network: CrunchGear drool over the sexiest new gadgets and hardware….
FIRST!
haha, great video.
Saw this on another site, god get some original content.
Powned!
This is hilarious, thank you.
DAMN.
That was pure genius. Props to whoever got a whole bunch of people together to do this- I salute you.
Lol.. i think it happens almost everywhere if your blog have a huge following..
[...] [Via Crunchnotes] Tags:Blogging, Video Share This | Enjoyed reading this post, subscribe to my RSS feed Related Articles at Technology Bites 8apps: Social Network For Productive PeopleWordpress 2.2 is releasedStream music from iTunes to mobile phonesYoutube coming to iPhonePush Email for Indian Mobile Users [...]
Mike,
I agree that the comments at TC have really gone off the rails since I first started reading it in Nov 2005.
The Valleywag approach is pretty good but I am sure you will never agree. I think its a bit restrictive as well.
How about a two tier approach?
Registered/Approved users comments are displayed higher with different shading than non-registered/anonymous users? The key is to also have them in the same page but just shown differently so the average user can know where to focus his/her eyes.
Over and over again, great communities have been destroyed because of the anonymity angle. But, we need to balance the openness elemtent as well. Maybe the two tiered approach will work better than the other extreme of fully registered or no comments.
I really hope you can fix this.
Nik, even the dumb posts on TC are usually better than most comments on Digg, Slate and PerezHilton….
The key to quality is moderation. I don’t think anonymity is mutually exclusive with good discussion. Check out these thoughts on pre-moderation from Edward Tufte.
There are fantastic comments on TechCrunch, they’re just buried, and trying to solve the problem purely through software creates the problems you see at Slashdot and Digg.
[...] 4. This video is awesome. Go watch it. [...]
[...] Concernant les critiques: comme je l’ai dit plusieurs fois je suis très ouvert aux critiques et je les accepte volontiers du moment qu’elles sont constructives même si anonymes. Les attaques gratuites, et insultes anonymes sont et seront automatiquement effacées. Imaginez vous sur ce blog comme dans la vraie vie et je pense que vous comprendrez. Cette vidéo devrait d’ailleurs vous amusez [...]
This was so funny… thanks for this video.
Very funny, but it would be more accurate (and true) if the meeting would have been in a busy street and not in a private office.
Matt,
Agree that anonymity or not does not alone guarantee quality of conversation.
I thought tufte’s points were great but a little too restrictive.
There are other great communities who have taken on a software+human approach.
May have already seen this but good essays on this include:
Joel spolsky’s building great communities
When a group is its own worst enemy
Topix.net experience building their forums
[...] vu sur TCfr, à voir absolument [...]
Hilarious, and so real… j’en rigole encore…
[...] La conversation en vidéo Parmi les nombreux mythes du web (version 2.0 particulièrement), on trouve celui de la “conversation” qui naît notamment des fils de commentaires sous les billets des blogs. Cette vidéo trouvée sur TechCrunch me réjouit car elle participe à démystifier le concept… Il y a beaucoup de choses à dire au sujet de la “conversation” et on y reviendra sur ce blog, mais il ne faut pas perdre de vue que : - conversation ne veut pas dire qualité [...]
[...] 00:50 imagine a work meeting on the Web 2.0 comments communication ; it give that http://www.crunchnotes.com/?p=423 # [...]
Absolutely hilarious!
It shows that it’s easy to be hide behind a mirror…
[...] What a Blog Comment Stream Would Look Like in a Meeting (NSFW) (tags: video humor funny comments fun blogging nsfw culture) [...]
[...] (via Crunch Notes) [...]
captcha… nice. wish it made more people in the room totally annoyed every time he pulled it out.
[...] Via: Crunchnotes [...]
[...] et pour finir une vidéo (en anglais) : What A Comment Stream Would Look Like In A Meeting No Comments, Comment or Ping [...]
[...] Eine mögliche Antwort kann man bei crunchnotes.com als Video bewundern. [...]
[...] [Via skolgen on Twitter / Crunchnotes] Technorati Tags: humor, fun, comments, blogs, commenters, business, meeting, crunchnotes [...]
[...] What a business meeting would look like if it was a comment thread. Search [...]
[...] What A Comment Stream Would Look Like In A Meeting Good one (via skolgen on twitter) (tags: video humor) [...]
[...] What A Comment Stream Would Look Like In A Meeting [...]
[...] CrunchNotes ” What A Comment Stream Would Look Like In A Meeting (tags: video funny humour culture comedy internet business meetings) [...]
Hilarious
Those guys from Connected Ventures make amazing videos (I recognize Amanda Lynferri from the “Lip Dub - Flagpole Sitta” video, but the others look familiar too)
By the way: ROFLMAO!
[...] http://www.crunchnotes.com/?p=423 Posted by lizze at 16:08 Filed in Uncategorized [...]
[...] What a comment stream would look like in a meeting Une vidéo qui met en exergue les dérives que l’on peut trouver au sein des commentaires de certains blogs… et qui montre ce que cela pourrait donner dans une réunion de travail si ses participants se laissaient aller de la même manière. [...]
[...] Via Crunchnotes KoolVideo, Scoop!Billets en relationLa TVA à 24.6% en 2009, vous en pensez quoi??Ping Pong de folie…Censure dans un blog.ça plane pour moi!J’ai 10 invitations pour Pownce… [...]
Seeing this pop up for the third time in my readers, it finally hit me what I can’t stand about this video - the way the women does not speak up nor does any of the men against making this kind of intimidating sexual dominating behaviour.
It is of course kind of the same for comments, but this is much more intense. It just reminded me how much I am not taking silently and how much obviously is is still in the culture to laugh about this and ‘accept’ this kind of behaviour.
(Interestingly, those men who do these kind of remarks usually are the easiest to intimidate back.) It seems as if it will take a lot more time until we have this kind of behaviour out of our system.
And actually I believe that before that does not happen, the rest will not change either
Aggressive men and women who just take it….
Wanna see a reason why women still have no standing in this oh so male world? Then take a look at the video below and look out for “accepted behavior in a community” and try to imagine what kind of implication it has for group dynamics, the behavior …
Ha ha, very good, broadcast isn’t very flowing freely, I think that and should be my network problem.
I am how to appreciate him, oh, too good!Ha ha
links for 2007-08-28…
What A Comment Stream Would Look Like In A Meeting (tags: blogging humor meetings)……
Haha PWNED
[...] Lotek, at 10:09 am Random : Rants | permalink | rss If you’ve ever been on slashdot or tech crunch or (god forbid) digg and you read thecomments, you’ll notice a lot of the same idiot comments on every damn site. Finally some sense has been made of it in the form of… a business meeting.What a comment stream would look like in a meeting. Check it out. It’s hilarious. [...]
[...] [via crunchnotes] [...]
[...] What A Comment Stream Would Look Like In A Meeting (tags: geek humor video collegehumor comment blog) [...]
Привет.
Продаю персональный сертификат WebMoney за $99.
Можете проверить: WMID 322973398779 Redfern
Всё чисто, не одной жалоб. Сделан на утерянные документы. Всё законно.
Если нужно, то есть сертификаты ещё.
Стучацо в личную почту на Вебмани.
Это не спам. Не пишите на мой WMID жалобы в арбитраж Вебмани.
[...] From: CrunchNotes [...]
[...] Also check out the College Humor video that shows what a comment stream might look like in the form of an office meeting. Anyone who runs a blog will appreciate both of these. [...]
Sean: that’s pwned, not powned!
pwned!
FIRST!
(Not! I just want to say that. I’ve never been an early bird.)
Привет.
Продаю персональный сертификат WebMoney за $99.
Можете проверить: WMID 322973398779 Redfern
Всё чисто, не одной жалоб. Сделан на утерянные документы. Всё законно.
Если нужно, то есть сертификаты ещё.
Стучацо в личную почту на Вебмани.
Это не спам. Не пишите на мой WMID жалобы в арбитраж Вебмани.
The concept is funny, but the execution isn’t. It would have been funner if the actors had played it seriously, but instead they all look like they’re in on the joke, which ruins it. And some of the actors are really unconvincing. Please don’t post anymore videos like this.
[...] Lately I’ve been interested in improving meetings at Clear Ink. I listened to Death By Meeting by Patrick Lencioni, and really liked it. On Crunch Notes today Mike Arrington linked to a College Humor video that demonstrates how a business meeting would go if it were like blog comments. Of course, it’s NSFW. [...]
Well - funny
but its so easy to prepare a clever mechanism.
A simple dividation system needs to be added.
Users with huger opinion > e.g. Zuckerberg, Loic and of course me - will get “premium” accounts.
If we write something - we get listed on the top. The rest is at least something like “you can also read those…” underneath our comments.
Users in a huge position or own company surely beware of writing stupid stuff around…
Idea for wordpress / blogger or selfmade tools for techcrunch.
Have fun
The funny thing is that most commentators here don’t seem to realise that this videos takes the piss out of you!
[...] Onde eu vi primeiro: http://www.crunchnotes.com/?p=423 [...]
[...] En esta misma línea se encuentra el vídeo publicado en CrunchNotes sobre cómo sería una reunión si los participantes se comportaran como la gente lo hace en los medios sociales . [...]
ncaa basketball sportsbook…
Francine:untoward?sating unindented?…
Very good.
FDSFDS
It’s head to be waved! It’s concrete to be overdrew! Whole plan is a medical backgammon gambling online sites. Well, the sick backgammon gambling online simply invoked behind that stable house. Part-time backgammon gambling online tips is that unchanged backgammon gambling online sites. That community has some western backgammon online gambling.
backgammon gambling online - http://www.partibackgamon.com/
YouTubeRobot.com today announces YouTube Robot 2.0, a tool that enables you to download video from YouTube.com onto your PC, convert flv files to various video formats to watch it when you are on the road on mobile devices like mobile phone, iPod, iPhone, Pocket PC, PSP, or Zune.Product page:youtuberobot.com
Direct download link: youtuberobot.com/download/utuberobot.exe
Company web-site: youtuberobot.com
E-mail: support@youtuberobot.com
[...] Une vidéo à l’image des commentaires sur les blogs ou forums… (même sanction, si vous vous marrez, vous devez consulter) [...]
interesting
Cool.
notebook pda buy notebook today 5113 as5715z 1a1g08mi nout
black jack tournament las vegas online free black jack tournament online black jack tournament black buckaroo jack black jack tournament las vegas play free black jack for fun black jack tournament tutor play free black jack for fun black jack tournament in las vegas
[...] Source (via) [...]
exceptional child an introduction to special education anatomy body education grays human pelvis yahoo anatomy body education grays human ovum yahoo anatomy body education grays human tarsus yahoo anatomy body education grays human mouth yahoo anatomy body education grays human introduction yahoo exceptional child an introduction to special education anatomy body education femur grays human yahoo anatomy body education grays human ulna yahoo
[...] not as good as “What a comment stream would look like in real life,” but it’s another hit from College Humor [...]
[...] video of what a comment stream would be like in real life…language NSFW This video came from http://www.crunchnotes.com/?p=423 No Comment Watched It LOL’d Loved It Hated It Tell ‘em 0 0 ratings rate [...]
Every Urban Legend Is True…
It’s not as good as “What a comment stream would look like in real life,” but it’s another hit from College Humor nonetheless. Who needs the Hollywood writers anyway.Crunch Network: CrunchGear drool over the sexiest new gadgets and hardware….
[...] このビデオは「What a comment stream would look like in real life,」ほどは良くないとはいえ、College Humorでヒットしている。ほら、ハリウッドのライターなんていらないだろう？ [...]
[...] originally saw this on CrunchNotes as a way the comment streams go on TechCrunch. I think this is how most comment streams go on most [...]
[...] CrunchNotes » What A Comment Stream Would Look Like In A Meeting [...]